Tuesday, November 6, 2007

Double Bind

This is Angelina, and I just wanted to share this poem. It's pretty awesome. It was published in Young Voices 2005/2006, when the writer was 19.

Double Bind

She was never a writer, though the passions was strong
Desire to create bubbled inside her
Rushed through her veins
Lava that could never solidify
Could never be forged into anything
She tried her hand again and again
But the harder she gripped at words
The quicker they melted to nothing

She was never a writer, barely a poet
The few carefully crafted phrases
That had been born in her spirit
And gently welded in her mind
Died after birth on the page
But she clung to them all her life

And as she was never a writer, she became a cutter
Found in the knife the eloquence
That the pen never evoked for her
In simple, painful strokes the desire
Was finally cooled, and she found her peace
She wrote her memoirs in scars
And died with the tragic twisted truth
That as long as she was a cutter, she could never be a writer

--- Ann Beatty

3 comments:

ENG3U Student said...

The line "She was never a writer, barely a poet" got me thinking. What's the difference between a writer and a poet? Did the author mean writer in the sense of being able to get down your ideas/thoughts rather than just having them? Does that mean everyone is a poet, even if they haven't ever written a poem?

The part about how she could not be both a writer and a cutter was interesting. The way I interpreted it was that she was expressing her emotions (poetry) through self-injury rather than writing. The fact that she had to go to such measures for some semblance of relief could be why she was "barely a poet".

I got the feeling that the girl in the poem was from a family where her parents punished her or simply discouraged her from expressing sadness or hurt. Growing up in that environment would probably lead to her having a lack of trust in herself, which explains why she couldn't be happy with what she wrote. With cutting, she found a way to externalize her internal pain. Isn't that what writing is as well? A way of expressing those feelings. What a morbid comparison.

Well, that's my $0.02.

- Amal

ENG3U Student said...

Angelina,

Are you a fan of the title of this poem?

I have a real difficulty understanding the importance of, and the difference between, the writer, the poet, and the cutter.

Btw, do you have any more info on this Young Voices 2005/2006 publication?

Regards,
Mr. G

ENG3U Student said...

speaking of young voices, why don't you post up your poem from young voices Angelina. Its a concrete poem and very emotional and touching

-Ielaf :)